THE TENEMENT DWELLERS’ REBELLION IN NEW YORK
By VICTOR ROUSSEAU
Harper’s Weekly, 25 January 1908

FOR six weeks New York has been in the throes of a rent rebellion. Starting among the crowded tenements of the lower East Side, it has spread like a fire wherever the poor are clustered; northward along the river front to the new slums of Harlem, eastward across the Williamsburg Bridge to Brooklyn. It has leaped over the business section and taken hold of Hoboken. Sporadic outbreaks have occurred in Jersey City and Weehawken. Tenants are organizing in Chicago. Two years ago the idea of a rent strike was first mooted in the crowded slums of the East Side. Spasmodic attempts were beaten down by the landlords. They pointed to Manhattan Island upon the map, narrow and overcrowded. Homes were to be had almost upon suffering. For every tenant who might depart fifty came crowding through the gates of Ellis Island. The landlords could afford to laugh.
To-day the landlord laughs no longer. He thinks of the new Williamsburg Bridge, the tunnels under the East River and Hudson, the Brooklyn Subway, opened almost simultaneously with the climax of the rent rebellion. He knows that in the Bronx stand rows of new, empty apartment houses, desperately offering one and two months’ free occupancy to tenants who will move in. Houses have been built more quickly than can be found occupants to move into them. The population of Manhattan Island has burst its chains.
That is why the people have gained many notable victories in this struggle; why in many instances landlord and “leaster” come humbly to the Committee of Ten at the Socialist party’s headquarters and sign agreements for a reduced rental. This passive resistance of half a million people has been carried to a partly successful conclusion by sheer inertia of numbers. You cannot physically dispossess five hundred thousand of New York’s inhabitants and fling their goods into the gutters.
Partly successful only; for it is the “leaster” or sub-landlord who has surrendered rather than the owner of large blocks of tenement houses. The leasters have come to the headquarters of the Socialists to the number of about twenty daily. In addition they have often compromised privately with their tenants. In some instances, frightened by their threatening demeanor, they have surrendered even in the courtroom.
The landlords themselves acknowledge the justice of their tenants’ grievances, but lay the blame to the economic conditions which exist on the crowded East Side. They say that a rental of twelve or thirteen dollars a month for two small rooms, or sixteen for a suite of three, scarcely more than recoups them for their investment. In Clinton, Cherry, and malodorous Eldridge streets whole families exist in tenements of two or three tiny rooms. Many of these are compelled, in addition, to take in lodgers. For such the only possible accommodation is upon the floor; attempt at privacy is out of the question.

“We pay thirteen dollars a month for these,” says a young Hungarian woman, crowding against the wall to allow us to pass between the table and the cooking range. “These” are two rooms together about the size of a medium hall bedroom; or rather one room, divided into a major and a minor portion by means of a curtain. In the smaller section there is just room for a bed, but one could not fall out on the farther side on account of the wall. Nor could one step round by the foot of it. The air is foul and stagnant. There is no place through which it could escape unless one used a suction pump from the outside. If you stirred it up with twenty electric fans it would only beat against the surrounding walls and ceiling and subside once more into its capacity of six by five by seven cubic feet. The larger section contains a lounge, a table, a small closet, four chairs, and a cooking range. Through the steamcoated windows one can see ten feet of courtyard shrouded with rows of draped clotheslines; and beyond, the dingy, dripping walls of the next tenement block.
“They are just married,” says the interpreter, “She says thank Heaven there are as yet no children. Her husband is sick with consumption. The doctor told her that if he sleeps in there—pointing behind the curtain—he is going to die. She does not know what they will do.”
An infant’s wail comes from the adjoining apartment. We enter; nothing is visible till we have taken off our glasses. The air, surcharged with moisture from the exhalations of its inhabitants, dims them as quickly as they can be wiped clean. Water drips from the lens of the camera when it is opened. A whole family lives here. The father displays with pride his youngest, a pale, anemic infant, already sickening from its surroundings. The atmosphere is filled with a mixed odor of soapy linen and cabbage, and one suspects that there is a pickled herring inside the closet.
The greater part of the East Sider’s earnings goes in the rent. He pays more, inch by inch, for his wretched, insanitary rooms than the inhabitant of the brownstone district. If he moves north he must allow for subway fares; and as a rule his business begins at daybreak and ends at bedtime. So he remains—and strikes.
So long as prosperous times cast their faint reflection over the East Side, these people were content to struggle along, living on stale bread, fish, and the produce hawked round by the pushcart man. Then the panic came. Business fell off. In the tailoring and fur trades alone some fifty thousand men were thrown out of employment. A no rent agitation was mooted.
Who are the leaders and inaugurators of this movement?
In the beginning there were none. It sprang into being, full fledged, from the misery of existence. Then the Socialist party, which numbers nearly all its adherents in the slum region, called a meeting at the headquarters at 313 Grand Street. A Committee of Ten was formed, under the direction of Executive Secretary Kaplan. Kaplan is a typical young Socialist leader, clean shaven, fluent, and suave. Another of the committee is Miss Florence Margolies, a schoolteacher. Other women have organized meetings and led the cheap rent crusade—Cecilia Arken; Pauline Newman, who works in a shirtwaist factory. When you attempt to exploit these as Joans of Arc everybody laughs at you. “It is the Socialist Party,” they answer. “We have no leaders.”
A general strike was urged. Landlords were notified that they must reduce their rents or none would be paid. Dispossess warrants were taken out. The moment that the city marshal had deposited the tenants with their goods upon the sidewalk, these were taken back into the rooms of other tenants in the same building. Pickets were stationed in front of tenement houses to warn away prospective occupiers. To meet such tactics demanded wholesale evictions or compromise. Many landlords came to compromise and ended with submission.
“Exhausted by toil in dark and ill ventilated shops,” reads the Socialist manifesto, “we return for our short rest to homes that are small, dark, and foul, unfit for cattle, much less for human beings. For these miserable holes in which we are forced to live we have to pay rent which takes the greater part of our wages…. The quarters provided for horses and dogs are in many cases superior to those in which we raise our children.”

It is not in the courts, nor in the crowded tenements, that the battle is being fought, but at the Socialist headquarters in Grand Street. Every morning one may see this small room filled with a dense throng of jostling humanity. Here and there some man or woman is addressing a little circle of auditors with frantic gesticulations, and these form vortices among the human ebb and flow, constantly changing as some newcomer gathers to himself a crowd of listeners. Tobacco smoke hangs in a gray haze under the ceiling. Crude pictures cover the walls. Women sit on the benches round the apartment, some wearing hats, some having their ritual wigs covered with shawls or mantillas. Men move hither and thither excitedly, gazing alternately at the empty dais along one end of the room, where the committee will shortly meet to confer with all and offer agreements for signature, and toward a closed door behind which the Ten are now conferring with landlords.
“You must take off two dollars,” says Executive Secretary Kaplan. It is clear at a glance that the case of the tenants lies altogether in the hands of the committee.
“I give one dollar,” protests the landlord, glancing into the hostile faces around him. “I cannot afford more.”
“Two dollars,” says Secretary Kaplan.
“Two dollars,” says Committeewoman Margolies.
A moment later the door is opened and a messenger runs into the larger room. He forces his way through the crowd to a blackboard on one wall, which bears, in large letters of chalk, the words “Pettibone Free,” and beneath them a long list of landlords who have capitulated. Yankele Isakowitz, of 903 Eldridge Street, is added to this. He has abated two dollars. An excited crowd gathers around.
Presently the committee files out to the dais, and the vortex rings dissolve into a tidal bore. A barricade of chairs and boxes is formed to beat back this human inundation.
“Shall the leaster turn out my children?” screams an aged woman in Yiddish, clutching the secretary by the arm. Her shawl has fallen from her head, and under her wig, grotesquely black, a few gray hairs straggle out over her forehead. Beside her a bent old man with a forked beard gesticulates furiously, but his voice is lost in the uproar, and nobody can hear him. He seizes the secretary’s left wrist and strokes his hand pleadingly. Another drags at the officer’s coat, and presently he is submerged, still struggling in this flood tide of humanity. Everybody is shouting at once. And then these individual men and women, hitherto presenting the appearance of a blind, chaotic aggregation, begin to strike the observer rather as a completed picture, a hundred voiced entity—the mob, rushing up from its secret, subterranean world of toil and suffering in futile vindication of the right to comfort, flung into the light by some volcanic fury of protest.
But they are not united. They are not organized. That is why the strike, spasmodic in its inception and sporadically conducted, resolved itself only into a series of local battles. Therefore the landlords, those who could afford some losses in order to hold out, resisted successfully the claims of the Socialists, which could be enforced only by moral stasion and the imposing but specious threats which they put forward. The landlords organized and the evictions began.

There was the same absence of unity in the attitude of the resisters during these proceedings. A futile demonstration in Rutgers Park, ordered, then countermanded, and finally dispersed by a dozen policemen, was followed by leaderless demonstrations against the city marshals who had charge of the dispossessions. All day the streets would be filled with little groups of excited men, interspersed with spots of bright-color formed by the women strikers’ red shawls. One felt a sense of something impending, some outbreak which might but never did arrive. Somebody spread rumors of an eviction; the groups coalesced, and from all parts of the network of mean streets between Williamsburg Bridge and the Elevated men came running in the same direction until stopped by the crowds in a choked street. A family was being evicted from the top story of a tenement. A red flag which had waved defiantly in the air was torn from the pole, fluttered into the street slowly, and became an old red petticoat, stained and torn in a dozen places. Between two files of police a marshal was carrying out the impedimenta of the family—a stove hissing and spluttering from the effects of an overturned jug of water; a table which stood unsteadily upon three legs; two broken chairs; a heap of garments and bedding; a bed, and then its four brass corner knobs; some crockery; a copper samovar, probably some relic from Russia. The family came out of the doorway, the woman gesticulating and shouting at the marshal, her children clutching at her skirts, and the man, seemingly cowed, and hurried out by the police in attendance. The crowd surged forward uncertainly; the police raised their clubs threateningly; and then everybody was running down the street again, leaving only the people at the windows of the neighboring tenements. Later it was reported that the neighbors had housed the family and their furniture. And so the war went on, gradually fizzling out in a series of compromises.
But the rebellion has had some measure of success for its justification. It has jolted the leaster system, perhaps beyond recovery. Then, again, there is the new Brooklyn Subway.
